|
| | 钱锺书可以说是“前无古人，后无来者” | | | 路边 ｜ 不採博客 ｜ 2026-09-12 | | | |
| 声明： 本消息或因风格和篇幅原因进行过编辑，但未经核实，也不代表我们的立场、观点或建议。如有侵权，联系秒删。[ 使用条款 ] |
scroll 0 1 钱锺书的“买椟还珠”
马：说到王、陈、钱这三大家，前两位您评价很高，相比之下，对钱锺书的评价似乎有所保留。我也读过一些学人对钱锺书的评价，似乎也如此。比如，叶公超说：“默存才性及基础均优，然颇有散钱无串之憾”（转引自卞孝萱：《钱锺书冒效鲁诗案——兼论〈围城〉人物董斜川及其他》，《中华文史论丛》2006年第4期）余英时说：“他有许多散钱，没有整个串成一串，可是他有很多小小的串子，串起来的，那些还是有用的，而且是永远有用的。……他后来走的路子是中国传统的、清朝人发展的一种笔记为主的著作……但是他确实没有一个大系统。他是注重小的结果，较少注重大判断，大判断他不是很在意的。他偶尔也有一些大判断，比如论中国诗与中国画有两种相反的途径，不过这样的东西不多。……他注重的是中西相同之处。他很少讲相异之处。……我认为钱学很难研究，因为他是没有一定形状的，你怎么去研究他？”（余英时：《谈钱锺书（与傅杰的问答）》（2008），载《师友记往：余英时怀旧集》，北京大学出版社，2013 年，第134—137页）王元化说：“钱锺书这个本领很厉害，博闻强记啊，他去世以后，记者来采访我，我说他是一个博闻强记的人，我只有这四个字的评语。他没有什么思想内容，他思想内容非常平凡，我说他一走了，没有人比他读书更多了。我说他读书之多令人叹服了……我从来没有把王国维、陈寅恪看作跟钱锺书一个档次的。那两个人我非常佩服，陈寅恪谈历史那是很有眼光的。……他连陈寅恪都看不起，他是非常狂的人。……他的《围城》我是不喜欢的。”（吴琦辛：《王元化谈话录》，上海人民出版社，2015 年，第445—447页）如此等等。
 | 点
击
图
片
看
原
图 |
钱锺书（1910年11月21日—1998年12月19日）
0 | | | |
0
8
ii
1
0
0
|
0
https://gears.popyard.space
https://www.popyard.space/img/logo_0.jpg
https://www.popyard.space
https://news.popyard.space
https://newsx.popyard.space
https://cn.popyard.space
https://plus.popyard.space
https://studio.popyard.space
https://studio.popyard.space
https://channel.popyard.space
https://adserver.popyard.space
news
八阕
新 闻
8
news-scroll
钱锺书可以说是“前无古人，后无来者”
16
2311770
2311770
0
4
路边
0
不採博客
2026-09-12
https://bbs.popyard.space
https://img5.angelyun.com/2026/8_12/73_116.jpg
desktop
google
underjeff
360playvid
0
0
normal
{ "object_name":"related_list","lan_0":"cn","sub_0":"他们把语文课文翻拍成“催泪大片”（组图）","sid_0":"16","rid_0":"2311498","gfw_0":"0","subject_0":"他们把语文课文翻拍成“催泪大片”（组图）","total":1 }
{ "json":"done-news-scroll-related-show","lan_0":"cn","sid_0":"16","rid_0":"2311498","src_0":"环球人物杂志","sub_0":"他们把语文课文翻拍成“催泪大片”","dat_0":"2026-09-12","sex_0":0,"gfw_0":0,"pic_0":"https://img5.angelyun.com/2026/8_12/oid320504_0.jpeg","lan_1":"cn","sid_1":"16","rid_1":"2311498","src_1":"环球人物杂志","sub_1":"他们把语文课文翻拍成“催泪大片”","dat_1":"2026-09-12","sex_1":0,"gfw_1":0,"pic_1":"https://img5.angelyun.com/2026/8_12/oid320504_1.jpeg","lan_2":"cn","sid_2":"16","rid_2":"2311498","src_2":"环球人物杂志","sub_2":"他们把语文课文翻拍成“催泪大片”","dat_2":"2026-09-12","sex_2":0,"gfw_2":0,"pic_2":"https://img5.angelyun.com/2026/8_12/oid320504_3.jpeg","lan_3":"cn","sid_3":"16","rid_3":"2311498","src_3":"环球人物杂志","sub_3":"他们把语文课文翻拍成“催泪大片”","dat_3":"2026-09-12","sex_3":0,"gfw_3":0,"pic_3":"https://img5.angelyun.com/2026/8_12/oid320504_4.jpeg","lan_4":"cn","sid_4":"16","rid_4":"2311498","src_4":"环球人物杂志","sub_4":"他们把语文课文翻拍成“催泪大片”","dat_4":"2026-09-12","sex_4":0,"gfw_4":0,"pic_4":"https://img5.angelyun.com/2026/8_12/oid320504_5.jpeg","lan_5":"cn","sid_5":"16","rid_5":"2311498","src_5":"环球人物杂志","sub_5":"他们把语文课文翻拍成“催泪大片”","dat_5":"2026-09-12","sex_5":0,"gfw_5":0,"pic_5":"https://img5.angelyun.com/2026/8_12/oid320504_7.jpeg","lan_6":"cn","sid_6":"16","rid_6":"2311498","src_6":"环球人物杂志","sub_6":"他们把语文课文翻拍成“催泪大片”","dat_6":"2026-09-12","sex_6":0,"gfw_6":0,"pic_6":"https://img5.angelyun.com/2026/8_12/oid320504_12.jpeg","lan_7":"cn","sid_7":"16","rid_7":"2311498","src_7":"环球人物杂志","sub_7":"他们把语文课文翻拍成“催泪大片”","dat_7":"2026-09-12","sex_7":0,"gfw_7":0,"pic_7":"https://img5.angelyun.com/2026/8_12/oid320504_13.jpeg","lan_8":"cn","sid_8":"16","rid_8":"2311498","src_8":"环球人物杂志","sub_8":"他们把语文课文翻拍成“催泪大片”","dat_8":"2026-09-12","sex_8":0,"gfw_8":0,"pic_8":"https://img5.angelyun.com/2026/8_12/oid320504_15.jpeg","lan_9":"cn","sid_9":"16","rid_9":"2311498","src_9":"环球人物杂志","sub_9":"他们把语文课文翻拍成“催泪大片”","dat_9":"2026-09-12","sex_9":0,"gfw_9":0,"pic_9":"https://img5.angelyun.com/2026/8_12/oid320504_16.jpeg","lan_10":"cn","sid_10":"16","rid_10":"2311498","src_10":"环球人物杂志","sub_10":"他们把语文课文翻拍成“催泪大片”","dat_10":"2026-09-12","sex_10":0,"gfw_10":0,"pic_10":"https://img5.angelyun.com/2026/8_12/oid320504_17.jpeg","total":11,"action":"fetch" }
点击朱笔，直抒胸臆